I'll admit it: I've been waiting -- like a huge geek-- all summer for this episode. And for the most part I was not disappointed.While the story of this episode is not particularly original, I thought that Hugh Laurie did an outstanding job. It is not often on House that he is able to portray any kind of poignant character development, but in Broken he gets more of the good stuff to work with, even while having less to work with (none of the other usual cast members are in this episode, save a brief appearance by Wilson.)
Apparently the writers had to completely break House down in order to build him back up again. While at Mayfield Psychiatric Hospital, we see him go through a painful detox (all in a montage, by the way -- which, yeah, a bit of a cop out. But at least it was a montage with Radiohead!) When House is done detoxing and decides to leave, the head psychiatrist -- Dr. Nolan -- tells him that he is not ready, and that if he does leave, said Dr. Nolan will not write him a recommendation to practice medicine. House sees this as blackmail (I think there was an inappropriate pun in there too) and decides to act out against the various psychiatrists and ward attendants.
The first hour of the two-hour episode is classic House, as far as his behavior. One remark, to a suicidal girl in the ward, bordered on cruelty: "So how disappointed were you when you woke up in the ER and you were still alive...and a loser."
However, somewhere along the way he begins to actually show some character growth, which I actually found extremely refreshing! I am not sure if they are going to keep building on this. My one complaint about House, as a series, is that the writers are not exceptionally talented at crafting complicated characters. A lot of what makes House great is Hugh Laurie. And yes, the character is extremely interesting -- perhaps due to his very archetypal nature. However, the writers never allow him to progress beyond a certain point.
As I stated already, the story here -- while clearly well executed -- is not very original. You may guess from the title of this review that I found a lot of similarities between this episode and Girl, Interrupted. In that film, Winona Ryder's character refuses to take her medication. Finally, after a tragedy takes place involving one of her fellow ward-mates, she decides that she wants to get better -- even though this new compliance earns her grief from some of the other patients that she has befriended. The exact same formula is played out in this episode. After House inadvertently causes one of the fellow patients to jump off of a building (he thought that he could fly) he sort of snaps. After this event he is compliant, and even goes on anti-depressants.
What I really enjoyed about this episode was the relationship between House and Dr. Nolan, and I hope that we see more of it in the future. I also really loved the mini-romance between House and Lydia (played by Franka Potente, of Run Lola Run fame.) There was something extremely sweet and innocent about their relationship, which is something I did not think House was capable of. This is leaving aside, of course, the fact that she is married. And since she is married, she inevitably leaves at the end of the episode -- dooming any further relationship. It is lovely while it lasts, though, and it is nice to see that House is capable of romantic emotions. Whether or not this experience is going to influence his relationship with Cuddy is yet to be seen. I think it would be a tricky balance to achieve, because House would not be as interesting if he were too "mushy."
All in all, I thought it was a good episode, and I am excited to see what happens next.

